Muhammad Samiullah, a private college student, was sent to juvenile detention for blasphemous comments he wrote on an exam. He told investigators his Norwegian cousins influenced him to do so, whom they thus threatened with an arrest warrant.
Syed Arif Hussain (uncle)
In January 2011, 17-year-old Pakistani Muslim student Muhammad Samiullah was arrested for blasphemy. He had allegedly written remarks on an exam he had taken which were insulting to Islam in an apparent bout of frustration. Because the remarks were blasphemous, they were never repeated publicly to any outlet or organization, so it is unclear what he actually wrote.
Upon his arrest, he was taken into juvenile detention, where he was beaten by police. He quickly apologized for what he had done and expressed remorse. The ultimate outcome of the case is uncertain.
“I used to pray five times a day and recite the Holy Quran. But when my cousins came, they influenced my beliefs and discouraged me from following the religion.” - Muhammad Samiullah
As the victim tells it, he had been experiencing distress for a few years, owing to the death of his father. He wanted to do well in school so he could give his family a better source of financial support. Some academic struggles led to frustration. In addition, he said, he had cousins in Norway who had visited him a couple of years prior, and they had told him of their secular lifestyle, apparently placing doubts about religion into his head. He blamed them for influencing him to write the blasphemous comments.
“I was under severe mental stress, and whatever I did was unintentional. I did not mean it, and I deeply regret what I did.” - Muhammad Samiullah
In the wake of the incident, publications in Pakistan reported that he may have been “brainwashed” by his cousins. Police then threatened that unless the two Pakistani-Norwegians turned themselves in, warrants would be issued for their arrest. Like Muhammad Samiullah’s ultimate fate, whether anything came of this threat is unclear.
Pakistani arrested for ‘blasphemous’ exam answer - The Seattle Times
Blasphemy allegations hit Norwegians - News in English Norway
How a teenager became a blasphemy suspect - The News International
Pakistan arrests teen for exam blasphemy - Deccan Herald
Pakistan: Drop Blasphemy Charges Against 17-Year-Old - Human Rights Watch
Blasphemy case: Angered by exam, student fudges answers - The Express Tribune
Pak police arrest Muslim student for blasphemy - The Indian Express
Pakistan is one of the most repressive countries in the world with regard to freedom of expression, including and especially religious freedom. Blasphemy (i.e. insults) against religion in general can result in imprisonment, while blasphemy against Islam carries the much harsher punishment of death. Both in terms of the aggressiveness with which the Islamic-conservative government prosecutes such cases, as well as the harshness of punishment, Pakistan remains one of the worst places on the planet to speak out against religion or religious fundamentalism.